Urban development has undergone a vast array of changes over the 150 years since the dawn of the industrial era. Social, political, cultural and economic systems, through revolutionary technologies and ideologies, have transformed the urban landscape into environments that attempt to accommodate fluctuations in the population. However, these complex systems often conflict and fail in their attempts to generate sustainable neighborhoods.
The purpose of this research is to illustrate the difficulties in deciding among trade-offs between social, political, cultural and economic systems that affect the sustainability of our neighborhoods.
In order to begin understanding these difficulties, one must have an understanding of what is meant by sustainability. And, although a familiar concept, one must know what defines a neighborhood as well.
SustainabilitySustainability is a term that has multiple definitions which are dependent upon the context in which it is represented. According to the New Merriam-Webster Dictionary, sustainability is defined as "provision of nourishment; endurance". This definition seems to fit a purely social context. However, our analysis focuses on planning for the future and reaching a balance between physical, social, cultural and economic elements of a neighborhood. A seemingly closer definition, as stated by the 1992 Rio Earth Summit, is one based on an environmental context. It states that sustainability" is the enablement of current populations to prepare and protect the environment for future generations". This definition holds true when looking at creating sustainability of the environment within the context of planning. It is very close to our goal of sustainability for neighborhoods but, not close enough. Given these previously mentioned definitions, none seem to fit into the framework of sustainable neighborhoods. However, this alludes to an important point: Sustainability is not one vision but many citizens' visions woven into a singular framework.When looking at multiple citizens' visions of sustainability, there are several issues that come to the forefront: diversity, citizen involvement, meeting needs, engagement and making transitions.
- Diversity
Diversity can foster success of communities, like neighborhoods. It is recognizing that these communities are made up of many different elements and support many different people. Importantly, diversity must be integrated into that singular vision.
- Citizen Involvement
This issue is important because it is about the citizen gaining ownership. If a citizen contributes to the creation or formation of a vison, then they gain ownership. As a result, the citizen will be more inclined to fulfill aspects of that vision based on their personal investment.
- Meeting Needs
Any vision of sustainability is about meeting the needs of the present and the future. If a human's needs are not met, then he/she will continue to find ways to meet their needs. These ways may not necessarily be beneficial in reaching that singular vision.
- Engagement
Once a citizen has become involved and invested themselves, then they are able to attain a level of engagement. This can be accomplished by gaining knowledge through education or technology.
- Making Transitions
Everyday humans make transitions, whether it is facing Colorado weather by wearing a short-sleeved shirt on a nice 70 degree day, returning home that evening and waking up the next moring to 7 inches of snow. As humans, we made a transition because we recognized the shifts in the weather patterns. As citizens, we must recognize these shifts within in our communities and personally act upon them by making transitions.
In addition to these issues at the forefront of building a single vision towards sustainability, one must look at the relationships and tradeoffs which occur within an existing or new community, like a neighborhood. There are 3 systems that are always in constant shift: carrying capacity, population and needs & behaviors.
Neighborhood
- Carrying Capacity
This is the limit at which an organism or an environment can no longer sustain itself. For example, a system like infrastructure, more specifically a 4 lane highway, could possibly carry about 500 automobiles every 30 minutes.
- Population
If the population increases then the carrying capacity that the previously mentioned highway could exceed its limit by supporting extra automobiles.
- Needs & Behaviors
If the carrying capacity of this 4 lane highway is exceeded, then a shift in the realtionship between the car and the highway will have to occur. As humans, our behavior will affect that shift and our behaviors will be a direct result of how our needs are being met. In this example, a portion of the population recognized the environmental and financial costs that could be saved by making a tradeoff from driving a personal automobile to an alternative mode of transportation, like a bus. This tradeoff resulted in a shift away from pressuring the carrying capacity of the highway and reducing it to a normal level.
In creating sustainable neighborhoods, a definition of a neighborhood is necessary. A neighborhood can be defined as an identifiable spatial unit in which people belong to which defines those small human groups which create the energy and character that can bring the larger community, town/city as well as the mosaic of subcultures, to life (A Pattern Language).